Save the replay.
Maybe because you have "extended catching" or whatsitcalled on at calhoupes scrips. I turned that off because it made the game a glitch fest.
Yeah, PC and No, the script doesn't need to be enabled for the diving catch animation. I haven't used the script in about 8-9 months now. And when I do use the script, I never have extended catch enabled. Like I said, I'll post a screen shot later!
I've posted many time before about the one-handed catch animation. I'll just mention but not go into detail again, the agility, jump, catch, awareness and role are the factors in determining which WR's & TE's do it!
When I do use the Calhoupe script these are the options I use:
Updated NFL Rules, TD Celebrations, More aggressive CPU on 4th down, TD and First Downs on Front of Line, Return Missed FG and Fumble Fix, Remove Sideline Limitations, QB Fumbles, Peyton Manning Signature Style and Super Bowl Intro!
Also because I have the "Fake FG Punt" play in some of the playbooks, many cpu teams use it given the situation!