The timeline of events will be this (I still have to add the "Madden Moments" to this list):
- Giants at Colts. December 28, 1958. NFL Championship Game. "The Greatest Game Ever Played". (Note: I'll do this one if I can find a roster that has these 2 teams. EDIT: Dummy me never realized the default roster has those teams).
- Cowboys at Packers, December 31, 1967. NFL Championship Game. "The Ice Bowl".
- Jets at Raiders, November 17, 1968. "The Heidi Bowl".
- Jets at Colts, January 12, 1969, Super Bowl III. "The Guarantee"
- Dolphins at Chiefs, December 25, 1971. AFC Divisional Playoffs. "Merry Christmas Miami" (Name in ESPN NFL 2K5). The Longest Game in NFL History.
- Raiders at Steelers, December 23, 1972. AFC Divisional Playoffs. "The Immaculate Reception".
- Dolphins at Raiders, December 21, 1974. AFC Divisional Playoffs. "The Sea of Hands".
- Cowboys at Vikings, December 28, 1975. NFC Divisional Playoffs. "The Hail Mary".
- Redskins at Cowboys, December 16, 1979. "The Final Comeback".
- Saints at 49ers, December 7, 1980. "The Aints' Biggest Choke".
- Chargers at Dolphins, January 2, 1982. AFC Divisional Playoffs. "Epic In Miami".
- Cowboys at 49ers, January 10, 1982. NFC Championship Game. "The Catch".
- Broncos at Browns, January 11, 1987. AFC Championship Game. "The Drive".
- 49ers at Bengals. September 20, 1987. "The 2 Second Miscalculation".
- Bengals at 49ers. January 22, 1989. Super Bowl XXIII. "The 49ers do it again".
- Bills at Giants. January 27, 1991. Super Bowl XXV. "Wide right".
- Oilers at Broncos. January 4, 1992. AFC Divisional Playoffs. "Houston's Hearts Ripped out".
- Oilers at Bills. January 3, 1993. AFC Wild Card Playoffs Game. "The Comeback".
- Colts at Bills. September 21, 1997. "The Colts' Collapse".
- Broncos at Packers. January 25, 1998. Super Bowl XXXII. "The Super Bowl Drive" Name in ESPN NFL 2K5). The Elway-copter.
- As much as I'd like to include the Music City Miracle, is not really possible to recreate the whole laterals included in that play.
- Rams at Titans. January 30, 2000. Super Bowl XXXIV. "A Yard Short".
- Rams at Patriots. February 2, 2002. XXXVI. "Vinatieri Strikes Again".
- Giants at 49ers. January 5, 2003. NFC Wild Card Playoffs Game. "The Botched Snap".
- Saints at Jaguars. December 21, 2003. "The River City Relay".
- Packers at Eagles. January 11, 2004. NFC Divisional Playoffs. "4th and 26".
This si the list pre-2007 BTW, there are still moments like "The Helmet Catch", also known as "Giant Upset" in M09.
Note: I deliberately delayed "The Ice Bowl" for a reason, does anybody know how to change an exh file so that the weather changes from "Sunny" to "Snowing"? Because that would help make it more realistic. That and how to change the stadium used for a game in the exh file.